|Back to Eclub Navigator|
Soy: Healthy or Harmful?
In recent years soy has emerged as a 'near perfect' food, with supporters claiming it can provide an ideal source of protein, lower cholesterol, protect against cancer and heart disease, reduce menopause symptoms, and prevent osteoporosis, among other things. But how did such a 'perfect' food emerge from a product that in 1913 was listed in the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) handbook not as a food but as an industrial product?
According to lipid specialist and nutritionist Mary Enig, PhD, "The reason there's so much soy in America is because they [the soy industry] started to plant soy to extract the oil from it and soy oil became a very large industry. Once they had as much oil as they did in the food supply they had a lot of soy protein residue left over, and since they can't feed it to animals, except in small amounts, they had to find another market."
And another market was what they found. To put it simply, after multi-million dollar figures spent on advertising and intense lobbying to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), about 74 percent of U.S. consumers now believe soy products are healthy.
If you're thinking the health claims surrounding soy sound too good to be true you just may be right. Soy has become another misunderstood food category, to be added to the ranks of coconut oil, saturated fats and vegetable oils. The two former have gained a negative reputation where a good one actually applies, but vegetable oil, along with soy, have emerged with sparkling reputations that cover up the truth.
For just a brief look at what's really going on, consider that numerous studies have found that soy products may:
Further, most soybeans are grown on farms that use toxic pesticides and herbicides, and many are from genetically engineered plants. When you consider that two-thirds of all manufactured food products contain some form of soy, it becomes clear just how many Americans are consuming GM products, whose long-term effects are completely unknown.
Perhaps the most disturbing of soy's ill-effects on health has to do with its phytoestrogens that can mimic the effects of the female hormone estrogen. These phytoestrogens have been found to have adverse effects on various human tissues, and drinking even two glasses of soy milk daily for one month has enough of the chemical to alter a woman's menstrual cycle. The FDA regulates estrogen-containing products, however no warnings exist on soy. Two senior toxicologists with the FDA. Daniel Sheehan and Daniel Doerge, have even come out saying "The public will be put at potential risk from soy isoflavones in soy protein isolate without adequate warning and information." Soy is particularly problematic for infants, and soy infant formulas should be avoided. It has been estimated that infants who are fed soy formula exclusively receive five birth control pills worth of estrogen every day.
There are some redeeming qualities to soy, however
these are found primarily in fermented soy products like tempeh, miso
and natto and soybean sprouts. If you want to get some health benefits
from soy, stick to these four forms and pass up the processed soy milks,
soy 'burgers', soy 'ice cream', soy 'cheese', and the myriad of other
soy junk foods that are so readily disguised as health foods.
GM contamination has been discovered in non-organic soya products.
A study by Professor Murphy and colleagues from the University of Glamorgan in Wales, tested 25 soya products from various retailers in South Wales and Yorkshire for the presence of GM varieties. Ten of the products (40 per cent) tested positive for GM ingredients, including eight which were labelled as GM-free or organic.
Robert Vint of Genetic Food Alert says the study raises a number of questions. "While this may well be part of a campaign by the biotech industry to oppose EU label laws and attack organic standards, it does highlight the need for manufacturers to take more care to keep products GM - free," says Vint.
One of the products tested and found to be contaminated - organic soya flour bought in Hebden Bridge - was certified by the Soil Association (SA). The level detected was just above the detection limit of 0. 1 per cent.
"The public doesn't want GM food, and the food
industry continues to struggle to keep GMOs out of products,"
says Peter Melchett, the SA's policy director. "If GM crops are
grown in this country we will see more contamination problems and consumers
will be faced with higher costs to stay GM-free."
PHILLIP DAY'S COMMENT: Another strong reason to dump the pesky bean.
Soy Index Newest Research On Why You Should Avoid Soy - by Sally Fallon & Mary G. Enig, Ph.D. - What was once a minor crop, listed in the 1913 US Department of Agriculture (USDA) handbook as an industrial product, now covers 72 million acres of American farmland.
Soy May Cause Cancer and Brain Damage - Two senior US government scientists have revealed that chemicals in soy could increase the risk of breast cancer in women, brain damage in both men and women, and abnormalities in infants.
The Trouble With Tofu: Soy and the Brain -by John D. MacArthur - "Tofu Shrinks Brain!" Not a science fiction scenario, this sobering soybean revelation is for real. But how did the "poster bean" of the '90s go wrong? Apparently, in many ways - none of which bode well for the brain.
Soy: Too Good to be True - by Brandon Finucan &
Charlotte Gerson - While even in 1966 there was considerable research
on the harmful substances within soybeans, you'll be hard pressed to find
articles today that claim soy is anything short of a miracle-food. As
soy gains more and more popularity through industry advertising, we are
moved once again to raise
Learn The Truth About The Historical Use Of Soy - Just How Much Soy Did Asians Eat? In short, not that much, and contrary to what the industry may claim, soy has never been a staple in Asia. A study of the history of soy use in Asia shows that the poor used it during times of extreme food shortage, and only when the soybeans were carefully prepared (e.g. by lengthy fermentation) to destroy the soy toxins. Yes, the Asians understood soy all right!
High Soy Diet During Pregnancy And Nursing May Cause Developmental Changes In Children - Two separate studies - one in animals and the other in humans, suggest that a diet high in soybeans and other legumes during pregnancy and breastfeeding may have a subtle but long-term impact on the development of children.
Concerns Regarding Soybeans - Some good information abstracted from an article written by Sally Fallon and Mary Enig, Ph.D. for Health Freedom News in September of 1995.
Soy Can Cause Severe Allergic Reactions - Soy, like its botanically-related cousin the peanut, could be responsible for severe, potentially fatal, cases of food allergy, particularly in children with asthma who are also very sensitive to peanuts.
Soy Supplements Fail to Help Menopause Symptoms - Supplements that contain concentrated phytoestrogens -- plant-based estrogens found in soy -- do not appear to improve mood, memory or menopause symptoms in women over age 45.
20/20 Feature on the Dangers of Soy - The ABC television news program 20/20 aired a feature story Friday June 8, 2000 on the dangers of soy.
Soy Formulas and the Effects of Isoflavones on the Thyroid - Environmental scientist and long-time campaigner against soy-based infant formulas, Dr Mike Fitzpatrick, warns about the risk of thyroid disease in infants fed soy formulas, high soy consumers and users of isoflavone supplements.
Pregnant Women Should Not Eat Soy Products - In-utero exposure to genistein increases the incidence of breast tumors.
Soybean Crisis - Jane Phillimore of The Observer addresses some of the concerns raised by new research about the safety of soy.
Response To Those Who Believe Soy Is Healthy - In a recent Letter to the Editor of the Townsend Letter, Sally Fallon and Dr. Mary Enig make the case that soy is not the health food that it is claimed to be. The soy campaign is, in fact, a case study in the use of propaganda to promote commercial interests, they allege.
Soy Can Lead to Kidney Stones - Those who are prone to the painful condition known as kidney stones may become more vulnerable to it through the consumption of soy.
PHILLIP DAY'S COMMENT: I periodically give soy the hammering it deserves, and those consuming the product, especially in its unfermented state (soy milk, soy meats, etc) need to make an informed decision about its continued use. The ubiquity and sneakiness of soy placement makes it hard to avoid. Small amounts of fermented soy, protein isolates, etc., in my estimation, are not the problem. The huge amounts of isoflavones consumed by those seeking to avoid cow's milk by drinking 'bean milk' are something else. Did you ever squeeze a soy bean and get milk out of it? You've got to hand it to Monsanto for the greatest PR job of all time. Take something useless and, worse, dangerous to your health, and sell it as a health food. Next thing you know, these people will be running our country!
What…? They're already running our country?